Arbitration: Are The Players Worth The Asking Price?

On Tuesday evening, 3 Yankees filed for arbitration since they couldn’t reach an agreement with the Yankees: Brett Gardner, Boone Logan & Russell Martin. With the Yankees only getting 3 players (Phil Hughes, David Robertson, Joba Chamberlain) out of the way, we might not know how ugly it could have gotten if all 6 of them filed for arbitration. Each of the Yankees had an asking price which competed with what the Yankees had offered them and I couldn’t help but have mixed opinions. Here was what it got me thinking, are the players really worth the asking price?

1. Russell Martin (Wanted $8.2 million, Offered $7 million)

Yankees catcher Russell Martin

Russell Martin made approximately $4 million in 2011, so to find that Martin is asking for double of what he made in 2011 was pretty shocking. Martin was a good asset to the Yankees in 2011 since he was able to whip the rotation into shape but his offensive performance faltered since he was constantly used by Joe Girardi. Martin was good defensively and he did hit 18 HR’s in 2011, but I doubt we will see Martin hit 18 HR’s again in 2012 if he becomes overused once again behind the plate.

If I Were Russell Martin: If I were him, I would have taken the $7 million and walked. He was getting a $3 million raise, so trying to push it by adding $1.2 million kind of shows that Martin really wants as much money as he could possibly get. Martin is a great catcher, but if I were him, I wouldn’t expect to see $8.2 million in 2012.

2. Boone Logan (Wanted $2.4 million, Offered $1.7 million)

Yankees LHP Boone Logan

In 2011, Boone Logan made $1.2 million for doing what he is supposed to do: come in and face lefties and that was exactly what he did. During the 2011 campaign vs. lefties, in 27.1 innings pitched, Logan had a 2.96 ERA, struck out 34 batters, held them to a .260 AVG and had a 1.24 WHIP. If I was just basing his lefty numbers on whether he deserves the $2.4 million I would say “why not,” but we aren’t basing everything just off of his lefty numbers, are we? Versus right handed hitters, Logan had a 4.40 ERA while pitching 14.1 innings. Logan struck out 12, held batters to a .262 AVG & had a 1.53 WHIP.

If I Were Boone Logan: If I were Boone Logan, I would have taken the $1.7 million that the Yankees offered. There had to be a reason that the Yankees said no to the $2.4 million in the first place and that had to be because Boone Logan can only pitch to left handed hitters. Honestly, just take the money and go Boone. Why make things difficult.

3. Brett Gardner (Wanted $3.2 million, Offered $2.4 million)

Yankees OF Brett Gardner

In 2011, Brett Gardner was paid a mere $529,000 for his civil service in left field. Before the 2011 season, the Yankees were thinking of platooning Gardner & Derek Jeter for the lead off spot just to see how the experiment worked out. Girardi pulled Gardner from the lead off spot so fast, Yankees fans didn’t even have time to blink. But if you take away the abysmal start to the 2011 campaign, Gardner performed to expectations. He had 49 stolen bases, a .345 OBP (which matched his 2009 OBP) & played remarkable defense for the Yankees, taking home the Fielding Bible Award for the second straight year.

If I Were Brett Gardner: If I were Brett Gardner I would have filed for arbitration the moment the Yankees tried to offer him $1.2 million less than what he deserves. Gardner has given service to the Yankees since coming up to the big leagues in June of 2008 and he is still making minor league money. It was time that Gardner got the raise that he deserved going into the 2012 campaign and hopefully the arbitrator can see that for himself.

These 3 Yankees are scheduled to meet with arbitrators sometime starting in February in Tampa, Florida. It is up to the arbitrators to see if they deserve the money, or if they should get what the Yankees offered them and stay quiet until next off season.

About Delia E.

Delia Enriquez is the managing editor of Yankees Fans Unite. She enjoys analyzing the New York Yankees whether it be their pitching, roster or their manager. You can follow her on twitter @dfiregirl4 for more tweets, analysis and opinion on the Yankees.

Posted on January 19, 2012, in Personal Opinion, Signings, Statistical Analysis and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 12 Comments.

  1. Delia – nice article on Lohud today. I support your position on Burnett.

  2. I’m gonna get crushed on this i’m sure but I believe everyone should get what they wanted except Logan.

    • Matt, I promised myself early today to only get mad (and ignore) one poster per blog. So you’l get no argument from me today. Just kidding Matt. I respect your opinions.

      • ha. thanks. Seriously though I feel Girardi abused the crap out of him last year and could have caused him some serious harm. If you want click this link

        that is his game log from baseball reference. look how many games he played in the early part of the season. It wasn’t fair to a player that is a catcher. Girardi should have found someone else when Cervelli went down.

        • Matt, I know he was used extensively for the 1st month or so. Much more then I’m sure the Yankees would have liked.

          I’m not sure there was any alternative though. Besides I think it’s wrong to blame Girardi. As far as I know Girardi plays the people Cashman makes available to him. I’m not sure who he could have called up to spell Martin. The Yankees clearly had no confidence in Montero as far as catching duties. Romine was in Double A to start the 2012 season I believe. I guess they could have used Gustavo Molina more. They used him a couple of games in mid April. But he’s as useless as knots on a log. Anyone else Cashman would have had to get from another team and make available to Cashman.

          • yeah i hear you. Even though Molina was garbage it still would have been good to save Martin’s knees.

            • Well as they say what’s done is done and can’t be undone. All we can to is look to this year. Im confident that won’t be the case again. First off, let’s hope if the Yankees to keep Cervelli (which right now that’s looks to be the case) that he doesn’t injure himself in ST again. But even if that were to be the case I think the Yankees have enough confidence in Romine to call him up to spell Martin should need be.

              • This took me a while to notice, but I realized Cervelli is injury prone. With all the concussions and then last season in Spring Training with his foot. He needs to keep himself healthy…

    • Well, I didn’t like the act that Martin asked for a little more than double of what he made in 2011. I think the Yankees offering him a $3 million raise was fine enough, but I think Martin pushed it just a bit.

      I completely agree with you 100% on Boone Logan though. 🙂

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: