Girardi’s Managing Style


Joe Girardi has definitely learned to relax more since his 1st year as Yankees manager when the Yankees missed the playoffs. He was way too uptight, testy with the media, and had to many rules. That attitude got him canned in Florida despite winning manager of the year, although you can blame that more on the craziness of Marlins owner Jeffrey Loria than Girardi. Entering his 5th season as Yankees manager he has improved greatly in these areas.  He still constantly tweaks with player rotations during the season , which can get irritable. However, due to the age of the team he is managing he doesn’t have much choice.

Girardi has a great bench and should utilize it. He has to utilize it because he has guys on his team that need days off. Alex Rodriguez and Derek Jeter definitely need lots of rest during the year so they are fresh and healthy for the stretch run. Eric Chavez and Eduardo Nunez are great options off the bench to replace them. In the outfield Andruw Jones is a great 4th outfielder and you are not loosing a whole lot when he is in the lineup. Joe Torre did not have the bench towards the end of his tenure that he did at the beginning so he did not use it often. Girardi has a great one so why not utilize it? It is a 162 game season and you can’t just put the same lineup out every game. In the bullpen Girardi is a by the book or in his case by the binder manager. He will very rarely go against what the matchups in his binder say. I think he does need to go with his gut more often and what he his eyes tell him about what the pitcher is doing.  However, I think managing the bullpen is probably his greatest strength as a manager. He will never pitch a guy until his arm falls off like Torre did. Torre pretty much killed the careers of Scott Proctor, Tanyon Sturtze, Paul Quantrill, and Tom Gordon by pitching them until their arm’s almost fell off. Girardi will never pitch a guy more then 2 days in a row. It is good that he has such a deep bullpen that it is easy for him to do that. Girardi is willing to trust everybody in his bullpen while Torre only trusted a selective few. This not to suggest Girardi is in Torre’s league as a manger don’t get me wrong, but it is one thing he did better. There is nothing wrong with Girardi’s in season competition. It should keep everybody on edge and make everybody raise their game. If players do not raise their game when challenged by another player then it is on them and not on the manager.

I am a bigger Girardi fan than a lot of fans are. People do not realize that managing the Yankees is a difficult job and not anybody can do it. Sure you are handed an extremely talented team last year but managing the egos, media, fans, and expectations can be really stressful. You try being the person to tell Derek Jeter he needs the day off or the one to bench Jorge Posada last season. I think Girardi does a really good job. Sure I and pretty much everybody else would like to see him make more decisions based off feel for the game but nobody is perfect.  It will be intriguing to see how Girardi continues to evolve as a manager.

About Matthew B

I am a student at William Paterson University and studying to become a sportswriter. I have a huge passion for the Yankees and love sharing my opinions on them. I can analyze every aspect of the Yankees very well. I am very active on Twitter so feel free to contact me there Twitter: @RAYROBERT9

Posted on March 4, 2012, in Personal Opinion and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 10 Comments.

  1. Nice article Matthew. I don’t think Girardi is going anywhere. I can see him be the manager of the Yankees for awhile and surpassing Torre with wins.

    Girardi and his binder do annoy me at times but he isn’t controversial and usually says all the right things.

  2. I agree Joe needs to manage more on feel sometimes. He often seems indecisive on things and uses the binder as a crutch. Now that he’s got a WS ring and 4 yrs with the team, I’d like to see him be more sure of himself and do what he feels rather than what the #s say. It’s like he follows the #s so if it doesn’t work he can say “well, it was the right move by the numbers”.

    The biggest challenge he will continue to face as Yankee manager is dealing with the aging players. It was Posada, now its Jeter and ARod. If at some point this yr or in years ahead they aren’t the right guy – he has to be able to move them down in the lineup or play someone else. Def not an easy thing to do with 2 future HOf’ers but it will become a neccessity.

    • The last thing I’m worried about is Jeter and A-Rod on this team. The Yanks were second in runs last year with sub par performances and injuries. A-Rod and Jeter are immortals not Posada. The worst move Torre ever made was moving A-Rod down in the line-up. The Yanks will go as far as their pitching will take them. The starting 5 are always the key in baseball. The Yanks offense is much better than the Rays and Phillies, but is the pitching.

  3. Dr. Fish…………… are acting like a child. if it wasn’t your pal, Ballpark, you would care less.
    Listen…uyf1950 complained about him, Ken(OR) wrote you twice about him, Matthew did
    not give him the response he wanted…so he took his 20 years of knowledge, and left.
    I get the “Dude” jive this morning, from him……..and gave it back to him.
    And all day I get you, your name calling, and dumb lectures.
    He left on his own, he can come back on his own. You should stand down, and mind your own business. And again, I am dam tired of you calling me names, and saying I’m a sick person.
    Look in the mirror……do you see a moron?

  4. As Rodney “ouch,ouch,ouch” King once said “why can’t we all just get along?”

  5. Fish….. Where is Dan L.?

  6. Been catching up and I don’t see any posts from him…..always enjoyed his minor league knowledge.

  7. Joe does a great job overall. The only things I would fault him on last year were: His dogged loyalty to talentless Ramiro Pena, Luis Ayala, and Chris Dickerson; and playing Martin too much at the beginning of the season.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: